Skip to main content

Robertson IP

A desk with a calculator, notebook, pencil, glasses and ring binders

Is a patent worth the cost?

People often ask me this at the end of a first consultation, once they have explained the invention and heard what the process involves. I can’t give a general answer, because it depends more on the business plan than on the invention. What I can do is set out the costs and the questions I would ask.

The costs

Taking a UK application from drafting to grant with us typically costs £5,400 to £7,200 including VAT at 20% (business clients: £4,500 to £6,000 + VAT at 20%), plus UK IPO fees from £405. That is spread over the two to four years the application takes. After grant, the IPO charges a renewal fee every year from the fifth year onwards, starting at £90 and reaching £810 in the twentieth.

Filing abroad costs a good deal more, because every country or region has its own official fees and most need a local agent and a translation. You don’t have to decide about that straight away. A UK filing gives you twelve months to decide where else to file while keeping your UK date.

What you get for it

A granted UK patent lets you stop others making, using, selling or importing the invention in the UK for up to 20 years. You can license it or sell it, and investors will usually ask whether you have one. It won’t enforce itself, though. If someone copies you, you have to take action, and that has a cost of its own.

When I think it is likely to pay off

I’m generally positive when the product will be on sale for a number of years, when a competitor could copy it easily once they had seen it, and when the margins or the investment plans can carry the cost. It also matters that you would find out about a copy, which is easy for a consumer product sold in shops and much harder for an improvement to a factory process.

When I think it is less likely to

If the product will be replaced within a year or two, it may be out of date before the patent is granted. If the invention is a process that nobody outside your premises will ever see, keeping it confidential can protect it for longer than a patent would, and costs nothing to file. If what sells the product is how it looks or what it is called, a registered design or a trade mark will often do more for less money.

The most common reason applications fail is that the invention turns out not to be new. You can make a first check yourself on Espacenet, the European Patent Office’s free database. Please don’t describe your invention to an AI chatbot, and be careful what you type into Google or other online searches. You have no control over what happens to that information, and an invention should be kept confidential until the application is filed. A professional search costs £720 including VAT at 20% (business clients: £600 + VAT at 20%), plus the search provider’s fee of £250 to £300, and goes a good deal further, although no search can guarantee that nothing relevant exists.

What I learnt as an examiner

I examined patent applications at the UK IPO for seven years. Many of the applications that failed had been drafted without anyone looking at the prior art first. When the examiner’s search found something close, the applicant needed to narrow the claims with a feature that set the invention apart, and that feature had to be in the application as filed, because nothing new can be added afterwards. Where the description was thin, there was nothing to fall back on.

So it is worth searching before drafting, so that the application is written with the closest prior art in mind, and it is better to put too much detail into the description than too little.

If you would like to talk through whether a patent makes sense for your invention, you can book a free initial consultation.

Photo by Cht Gsml on Unsplash

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *